Last night on Twitter, Derek Kompare (@d_kompare) posed the question:
“Hey tweeps: is it still called “product placement” or do all the cool kids say “product integration”? Thanks.”
I responded by saying Product Placement stands out (often badly) and Product Integration is much more organic and subtle. I also said I would look into more examples this morning. So I’ve realized that I gave the idealistic definition of Product Integration.
Technically, Product Integration involves characters taking about a product within the show/film. Check out these articles for thoughts and examples that way, NYTimes from 2006 and an example of Coke in American Idol.
All that being said, I would like to put out my definition of Product Integration. A well done product integration helps a brand stick out in our minds and compels us to buy/use a product or service. It is barely mentioned or shown, but its impact on the story is real.
My favorite example is the NetJets integration in the Liam Neeson film Taken. The story revolves around Neeson’s character’s daughter (Kim) being taken from an apartment and Neeson’s whirlwind journey to get her back within 96 hours. He goes to tell Kim’s mother and step-father that she’s been taken. And the conversation continues as follows (not exact):
Step-Father: What can I do to help?
Dad: You have a NetJets membership. Get me a plane to Paris.
The next scene is Neeson riding in a private plane listening to his daughter’s voice as she was taken. The point of this scene is a father and his single minded quest. But the underlying message is that he wouldn’t have gotten there in time without using this service. There is never a logo, or even another mention.
I could argue that the entire film Fever Pitch is product integration. It is 2 hours of Red Sox placement. And that movie is one of my favorite romantic comedies.
Another example is music placement on popular shows like Grey’s Anatomy, Private Practice, or One Tree Hill. The music becomes another character (per the music supervisor’s design). At the end of each of these shows, it tells us that music by these artists is available on iTunes. Grey’s and Private Practice also have music guides on their websites. I have bought a fair amount of music because it was very artfully done.
In contrast, Product Placement is obvious, annoying, and a real turnoff. Although articles point to the Coca-Cola cups on the judges’ table for American Idol as an example of product integration. I see this as product placement at its worst. I know Coca-Cola is a sponsor of American Idol, but it just makes me want to throw something. There is no organic purpose for those labelled cups to be there.
So, do you agree with my differentiation? Or do you think it should be something else? What are your favorite examples?